Why Violet remembers Jacques alias Lemony, Violet's real father

'''"His full name," Duncan said, flipping through his notebook, "is Jacques Snicket." "That sounds familiar," Violet said. "I'm not surprised," Duncan said. "Jacques Snicket is the brother of a man who — "''' The Vile Village chapter 12

In the book The Vile Village Duncan mentions Jacques's full name, Jacques Snicket. Violet founds his surname familiar, which lead fans to only one theory so far: Lemony Snicket is Violet's real father.

Due to the fact Beatrice met and married Bertrand in a short period of time after breaking up with Lemony, it is considered if Lemony and Beatrice didn't have one last night together before she lesft him for good. Duo to some fans, this theory is supposed to explain Lemony feels so dedicated to the Baudelaire children and especially to Violet. But he could be deciated to them simply because of the fact they were his fovered loved ex-fianceé's children. To how Violet remembers Jacques the theory comes up with a solution that Beatrice brought Violet to Snickets when she was a baby to show them their niece. Another theory argument is that Beatrice's first born child should have been named Lemony if a boy and Violet if a girl. This applied to the first born only, because of Klaus being a boy among his two sisters. Though due to this idea Klaus should have been named Bertrand as Bertrand's first child. Moreover due to chapter 14 of The End the name Lemony could have been chosen, because of Baudelaire's family custom of naming children after their acquintances who died as Lemony was thought to be dad when on lam.

Sources:

About the ‘’Lemony is Violet’s real father’’ theory